ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL SUMMARY REPORT
CV-2010-0000382
Return to Appeals Index
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL SUMMARY REPORT HTML19
09-26-2024
COURT CASE#: CV-2010-0000382
PETITIONER: IDAHO GROUND WATERS
APPROPRIATORS INC
IN THE MATTER OF DISTRIBUTION OF WATER
TO VARIOUS WATER RIGHTS HELD BY OR FOR
THE BENEFIT OF A&B IRRIGATION DISTRICT,
AMERICAN FALLS RESERVOIR DISTRICT #2,
BURLEY IRRIGATION DISTRICT, MILNER
IRRIGATION DISTRICT, MINIDOKA IRRIGATION
DISTRICT, NORTH SIDE CANAL COMPANY AND
TWIN FALLS CANAL COMPANY
**** PARTIES INVOLVED ****
NO ACTIVE PARTIES TO THE APPEAL
**** ROA ENTRIES ****
07-21-2010 IGWA'S PETITION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
(FINAL ORDER RE: APRIL 2010 FORECAST SUPPLY
DATED JUNE 24, 2010) (GOODING COUNTY)
07-22-2010 NOTICE OF REASSIGNMENT
07-27-2010 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT REQUEST FOR
A STATUS CONFERENCE
07-28-2010 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT RESPONSE TO 07-28-2010
IGWA AND POCATELLO'S MOTION FOR STAY AND
CONSOLIDATION AND MOTION TO RENUMBER APPEALS
IN GOODING COUNTY CASE NO CV-2008-00551
07-29-2010 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO RENUMBER AND ORDER 07-29-2010
CONSOLIDATING PROCEEDINGS INVOLVING
PETITIONS FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW OF
"METHODOLOGY ORDER" AND "AS-APPLIED ORDER"
08-03-2010 PROCEDURAL ORDER GOVERNING JUDICIAL REVIEW
OF FINAL ORDERS OF DIRECTOR OF IDAHO
DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
SETTLED RECORD & LODGING OF TRANSCRIPT ZB 09-21-2010 0500
DUE: 09/21/10 HS 02-11-2011
08-03-2010 ORAL ARGUMENT - 02/11/11 HV 02-11-2011 0130
08-03-2010 GROUND WATER USERS' INITIAL ISSUES FOR
JUDICIAL REVIEW (FINAL METHODOLOGY ORDER
AND FINAL AS-APPLIED ORDER) (FAX)
08-12-2010 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL
08-12-2010 MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO LODGE MG 08-16-2010
AGENCY RECORD
08-16-2010 ORDER APPROVING EXTENSION OF TIME TO LODGE
AGENCY TRANSCRIPT AND RECORD
LODGING OF TRANSCRIPT DUE: 10/01/10 ZB 10-01-2010 0500
SETTLED TRANSCRIPT/RECORD DUE: 10/29/10 ZB 10-29-2010 0500
09-29-2010 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT MOTIONS FOR MD 10-15-2010
CONSOLIDATION AND FOR EXPEDITED HEARING
09-29-2010 NOTICE OF HEARING HV 10-08-2010 0130
10-01-2010 NOTICE OF LODGING TRANSCRIPTS AND RECORDS
WITH AGENCY
10-12-2010 (FAX) IDWR RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO SWC'S 10-12-2010
JOINT MOTION FOR CONSOLIDATION
10-14-2010 (FAX) GROUND WATER USERS' RESPONSE IN 10-14-2010
OPPOSITION TO SURFACE WATER COALITION'S
JOINT MOTION FOR CONSOLIDATION
10-14-2010 (FAX) POCATELLO'S OBJECTION TO AGENCY RECORD
10-15-2010 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S OBJECTION TO
AGENCY RECORD
10-15-2010 (FAX) GROUND WATER USERS' OBJECTION TO AGENCY
TRANSCRIPT & RECORD AND REQUEST FOR
EXTENSION OF TIME
10-15-2010 ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR CONSOLIDATION
10-21-2010 MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO LODGE THE MG 10-21-2010
SETTLED AGENCY TRANSCRIPT AND RECORD WITH
THE COURT
10-21-2010 ORDER APPROVING EXTENSION OF TIME TO LODGE
THE SETTLED AGENCY TRANSCRIPT AND RECORD
WITH THE COURT
SETTLED TRANSCRIPT/RECORD DUE: 12/03/10 ZV 12-03-2010 0500
10-21-2010 ORDER AMENDING DATE FOR ORAL ARGUMENT ON HV 03-14-2011 0130
PETITIONS FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
ORAL ARGUMENT SET FOR 3/14/11
10-22-2010 (FAX) GROUND WATER USERS' SUPPLEMENT TO
OBJECTION TO AGENCY TRANSCRIPT & RECORD
11-01-2010 MOTION FOR LIMITED ADMISSION MG 11-02-2010
11-02-2010 ORDER ADMITTING COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE
ORDER EXCUSING LOCAL COUNSEL FROM APPEARING
12-02-2010 SECOND MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO LODGE MG 12-02-2010
THE SETTLED AGENCY TRANSCRIPT AND RECORD
WITH THE COUNTY
12-02-2010 SECOND ORDER APPROVING EXTENSION OF TIME TO
LODGE THE SETTLED AGENCY TRANSCRIPT AND
RECORD WITH THE COURT
SETTLED RECORD & TRANSCRIPT DUE: 12/17/1O ZB 12-17-2010 0500
12-10-2010 (FAX) MOTION FOR STAY MG 12-13-2010
12-13-2010 ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR STAY
12-17-2010 (FAX) NOTICE OF LODGING TRANSCRIPTS AND
RECORDS WITH THE DISTRICT COURT
12-17-2010 ORDER SETTLING THE AGENCY TRANSCRIPT AND
RECORD
12-17-2010 LODGED: AGENCY TRANSCRIPTS (3)
08-29-2013 NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF REPRESENTATIVE
09-06-2013 NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF REPRESENTATIVE
10-25-2013 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT MOTION TO MD 11-12-2013
LIFT STAY / JOINT MOTION TO EXPEDITE
10-25-2013 NOTICE OF HEARING HH 11-04-2013 0130
10-29-2013 (FAX) CITY OF POCATELLO'S RESPONSE TO SURFACE 10-29-2013
WATER COALITION'S JOINT MOTION TO LIFT
STAY / JOINT MOTION TO EXPEDITE
10-30-2013 (FAX) IGWA'S OPPOSITION TO SURFACE WATER 10-30-2013
COALITION'S JOINT MOTION TO IFT STAY
10-30-2013 (FAX) DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCE'S RESPONSE 10-30-2013
TO SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT MOTION
TO LIFT STAY
11-04-2013 HEARING HELD HH 11-04-2013 0130
11-04-2013 MINUTES
11-12-2013 ORDER DENYING MOTIONS TO LIFT STAY
11-12-2013 ORDER GRANTING MOTIONS TO CONSOLIDATE
01-09-2014 NOTICE OF HEARING HH 02-03-2014 0130
01-29-2014 (FAX) MOTION TO REMAND METHODOLOGY ORDER TO MF 01-29-2014
IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
02-03-2014 HEARING HELD HH 02-03-2014 0130
02-03-2014 MINUTES
02-03-2014 NOTICE OF HEARING ON MOTION TO REMAND HH 02-24-2014 0130
RESPONSES TO MOTION TO REMAND DUE: 2/14/14 RB 02-14-2014 0500
REPLY FROM IDWR DUE: 2/21/14 RB 02-21-2014 0500
02-03-2014 NOTICE CONTINUING STATUS CONFERENCE HH 02-24-2014 0130
02-13-2014 (FAX) CITY OF POCATELLO'S RESPONSE TO MOTION 02-13-2014
TO REMAND METHODOLOGY ORDER TO IDAHO
DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
02-14-2014 SURFACE WATER COALITION RESPONSE IN 02-14-2014
OPPOSITION TO IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER
RESOURCES MOTION TO REMAND METHODOLOGY
ORDER
02-21-2014 IDWR REPLY TO SWC AND POCATELLO RESPONSES TO 02-21-2014
IDWRS MOTION TO REMAND METHODOLOGY ORDER
02-24-2014 HEARING HELD HH 02-24-2014 0130
02-24-2014 MINUTES
02-24-2014 ORDER AMENDING IN PART PROCEDURAL ORDER HS 07-09-2014 0130
GOVERNING JUDICIAL REVIEW OF FINAL ORDERS
OF DIRECTOR OF IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER
RESOURCES
DEADLINE TO LODGE AGENCY RECORD WITH ZB 03-10-2014 0500
IDWR: 03/10/14
DEADLINE TO LODGE TRANSCRIPT: 03/10/14 ZB 03-10-2104 0500
SETTLEMENT OF TRANSCRIPT AND RECORD: ZB 04-07-2014 0500
04/07/14
PETITIONERS' BRIEFS DUE: 04/14/14 BB 05-12-2014 0500
RESPONDENTS' BRIEFS DUE: 05/12/14 BB 06-09-2014 0500
REPLY BRIEFS DUE: 06/02/14 BB 06-30-2014 0500
02-24-2014 ORAL ARGUMENT SET HV 07-09-2014 0130
03-10-2014 NOTICE OF LODGING SUPPLEMENTAL AGENCY RECORD
WITH THE AGENCY
03-21-2014 CITY OF POCATELLO OBJECTION TO THE CLERKS
RECORD
03-21-2014 SURFACE WATER COALITIONS OBJECTION TO AGENCY
RECORD
04-04-2014 ORDER SETTLING THE AGENCY RECORD AND
TRANSCRIPT
04-04-2014 NOTICE OF LODGING SUPPLEMENTAL AGENCY RECORD
WITH THE DISTRICT COURT
05-08-2014 (FAX) JOINT MOTION TO AMEND ORAL ARGUMENT MG 05-08-2014
AND BRIEFING SCHEDULE
05-08-2014 ORDER GRANTING JOINT MOTION TO AMEND ORAL
ARGUMENT AND BRIEFING SCHEDULE /ORDER
VACATING AND RESETTING ORAL ARGUMENT
PETITIONERS' BRIEFS DUE: 06/13/14 BB 06-13-2014 0500
RESPONSENTS' BRIEFS DUE: 07/11/14 BB 07-11-2014 0500
REPLY BRIEFS DUE: 08/01/14 BB 08-01-2014 0500
05-08-2014 ORAL ARGUMENT SET: 08/13/14 HH 08-13-2014 0130
06-13-2014 LODGED: SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT
OPENING BRIEF (METHODOLOGY APPEAL)
06-13-2014 LODGED: SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT
OPENING BRIEF (AS APPLIED APPEAL)
06-16-2014 LODGED: CITY OF POCATELLO'S OPENING BRIEF
ON JUDICIAL REVIEW (METHODOLOGY ORDER)
06-16-2014 LODGED: CITY OF POCATELLO'S OPENING BRIEF
ON JUDICIAL REVIEW (AS APPLIED ORDER)
06-16-2014 LODGED: IGWA'S OPENING BRIEF
07-09-2014 (FAX) UNOPPOSED MOTION TO EXTEND BRIEFING MG 07-09-2014
SCHEDULE
07-09-2014 (FAX) AFFIDAVIT OF GARICK L BAXTER IN SUPPORT
OF UNOPPOSED MOTION TO EXTEND BRIEFING
SCHEDULING
07-09-2014 ORDER GRANTING IDWR MOTION TO EXTEND
BRIEFING SCHEDULE
RESPONSE BRIEFS DUE: 07/14/14 BB 07-14-2014 0500
REPLY BRIEFS DUE: 08/04/14 BB 08-04-2014 0500
07-14-2014 LODGED: SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT
RESPONSE BRIEF (METHODOLOGY APPEAL)
07-14-2014 LDGD: BRIEF OF GARY SPACKMAN AND IDWR
07-15-2014 LODGED: CITY OF POCATELLO'S RESPONSE BRIEF ON
JUDICIAL REVIEW (METHODOLOGY ORDER)
07-15-2014 LODGED: CITY OF POCATELLO'S RESPONSE BRIEF ON
JUDICIAL REVIEW (AS APPLIED ORDER)
07-16-2014 LODGED: IGWA'S RESPONSE BRIEF
07-31-2014 LODGED: CORRECTED BRIEF OF GARY SPACKMAN AND
IDWR
07-31-2014 IDWR RESPONDENTS' NOTICE OF ERRATA / NOTICE
OF FILING OF CORRECTED BRIEF / NOTICE OF
FILING OF ELECTRONIC COPY OF CORRECTED
BRIEF
08-04-2014 SURFACE WATER COALITIONS JOINT REPLY BRIEF
(METHODOLOGY AND AS APPLIED APPEALS)
08-05-2014 LODGED: CITY OF POCATELLO'S REPLY BRIEF
08-13-2014 HEARING HELD HH 08-13-2014 0130
08-13-2014 MINUTES
09-26-2014 MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER ON PETITIONS
FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
09-26-2014 JUDGMENT 5B 11-07-2014
10-10-2014 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT PETITION MD 11-17-2014
FOR REHEARING
10-10-2014 IDWR RESPONDENTS' MOTION TO ALTER OR AMEND MD 11-17-2014
JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO I.R.C.P. 59(E)
10-14-2014 NOTICE OF HEARING HV 10-30-2014 0130
10-17-2014 (FAX) IGWA'S MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARING MG 10-20-2014
10-17-2014 (FAX) IGWA'S PETITION FOR REHEARING MD 11-17-2014
10-20-2014 ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARING
10-20-2014 ORDER VACATING AND RESETTING HEARING HH 11-13-2014 1000
10-24-2014 SURFACE WATER COALITION BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF
JOINT PETITION FOR REHEARING
10-31-2014 (FAX) LODGED: IGWA'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF
PETITION FOR REHEARING
11-13-2014 HEARING HELD HH 11-13-2014 1000
11-13-2014 MINUTES
11-17-2014 ORDER DENYING PETITIONS FOR REHEARING
11-17-2014 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO ALTER OR AMEND
JUDGMENT
12-24-2014 NOTICE OF APPEAL F/B IGWA 12-24-2014
12-30-2014 CITY OF POCATELLO'S NOTICE OF APPEAL 12-30-2014
01-05-2015 ORDER CONSOLIDATING APPEALS FOR ALL PURPOSES
01-06-2015 AMENDED ORDER CONSOLIDATING APPEALS FOR ALL
PURPOSES (TITLE CORRECTION)
01-16-2015 FYI - SUPREME COURT SUSPENDS ALL APPEAL DUE
DATES PENDING RESPONDENTS' MOTION TO
DISMISS APPEAL
01-23-2015 FYI - CITY OF POCATELLO'S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
NOTICE OF APPEAL
01-28-2015 ORDER GRANTING APPELLANT'S WITHDRAWAL
OF APPEAL AND SEVERING CONSOLIDATED
APPEAL NO 42776 - 42776 REMAINS SUSPENDED
PENDING RESPONDENT'S MOTION TO DISMISS
APPEAL
02-04-2015 REMITTITUR FROM IDAHO SUPREME COURT 02-04-2015
FOR SUPREME COURT DOCKET NO. 42778-2015
02-12-2015 CLERK'S RECORD ON APPEAL SERVED ON PARTIES
03-12-2015 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S OBJECTION TO 03-12-2015
CLERK'S RECORD
03-12-2015 NOTICE OF HEARING HH 04-01-2015 0100
03-12-2015 IGWA'S OBJECTION TO CLERK'S RECORD AND NOTICE HH 04-01-2015 0100
OF HEARING
04-01-2015 HEARING HELD HH 04-01-2015 0100
04-01-2015 MINUTES
04-01-2015 ORDER ON OBJECTIONS TO CLERKS RECORD
04-06-2015 CLERK'S SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD ON APPEAL SERVED
ON PARTIES
04-13-2015 CLERK'S SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD ON APPEAL MAILED
TO SUPREME COURT
04-17-2015 (FAX) IGWAS MOTION TO WITHDRAW NOTICE OF MF 04-17-2015
APPEAL
04-20-2015 ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL
04-20-2015 REMITTITUR FROM IDAHO SUPREME COURT 04-20-2015
04-29-2015 REMITTITUR
04-29-2015 CLOSED 04-29-2015
Return to Appeals Index