ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL SUMMARY REPORT
CV-2014-0001338
Return to Appeals Index
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL SUMMARY REPORT HTML19
04-24-2024
COURT CASE#: CV-2014-0001338
PETITIONER: RANGEN INC
RE: PETITIONS FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW OR
ACTIONS FOR DECLARATORY RELIEF OF
DECISIONS FROM THE IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF
WATER RESOURCES
**** PARTIES INVOLVED ****
RANGEN INC P ATTY: ROBYN M BRODY
" ATTY: FRITZ X HAEMMERLE
" ATTY: J JUSTIN MAY
GARY SPACKMAN, IN HIS R ATTY: GARRICK L BAXTER
IDAHO GROUND WATER I ATTY: THOMAS J BUDGE
FREMONT MADISON IRRIGATION I ATTY: JERRY R RIGBY
A&B IRRIGATION DISTRICT I ATTY: TRAVIS L THOMPSON
BURLEY IRRIGATION DISTRICT I ATTY: TRAVIS L THOMPSON
MILNER IRRIGATION DISTRICT I ATTY: TRAVIS L THOMPSON
NORTH SIDE CANAL COMPANY I ATTY: TRAVIS L THOMPSON
TWIN FALLS CANAL COMPANY I ATTY: TRAVIS L THOMPSON
AMERICAN FALLS RESEVOIR I ATTY: W KENT FLETCHER
MINIDOKA IRRIGATION DISTRI I ATTY: W KENT FLETCHER
CITY OF POCATELLO I ATTY: SARAH A KLAHN
**** ROA ENTRIES ****
03-24-2014 PETITION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
03-26-2014 NOTICE OF REASSIGNMENT
03-28-2014 PROCEDURAL ORDER GOVERNING JUDICIAL REVIEW OF
FINAL ORDER OF DIRECTOR OF IDAHO
DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
SETTLED RECORD AND TRANSCRIPT TO BE
LODGED W/COURT BY: 05/09/14 ZV 05-09-2014 0500
03-28-2014 ORAL ARGUMENT: 08/07/14 HV 08-07-2014 0130
04-03-2014 IGWA'S NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
04-04-2014 STATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL ISSUES
04-08-2014 (FAX) MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO LODGE MG 04-08-2014
AGENCY RECORD AND TRANSCRIPT
04-08-2014 ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
TO LODGE THE AGENCY RECORD AND TRANSCRIPT
SETTLED RECORD AND TRANSCRIPT TO BE LODGED
W/COURT BY: 05/28/14 ZS 05-28-2014 0500
04-08-2014 ORDER VACATING AND RESETTING ORAL ARGUMENT HS 08-28-2014 0130
04-09-2014 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL - RIGBY FOR
FREMONT MADISON IRRIGATION DISTRICT
04-09-2014 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL - THOMPSON
FLETCHER FOR IRRIGATION ENTITIES
04-10-2014 NOTICE OF APEARANCE OF COUNSEL - KLAHN FOR
CITY OF POCATELLO
04-10-2014 (FAX) MOTION TO AMEND CAPTION MG 04-22-2014
04-10-2014 (FAX) MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE MG 04-11-2014
04-11-2014 ORDER RE: MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE
04-22-2014 ORDER TREATING APPEARANCES AS MOTIONS TO
INTERVENE AND GRANTING SAME
04-25-2014 (FAX) IGWA'S MOTION TO STAY CURTAILMENT ORDER MW 04-29-2014
04-25-2014 (FAX) MOTION FOR EXPEDITED HEARING AND MG 04-25-2014
DECISION ON IGWA'S MOTION TO STAY
CURTAILMENT ORDER
04-25-2014 NOTICE OF HEARING HV 05-01-2014 0130
04-28-2014 AFFIDAVIT OF THOMAS J BUDGE IN SUPPORT OF
IGWA'S MOTION TO STAY CURTAILMENT ORDER
04-29-2014 (FAX) WITHDRAWAL OF IGWA'S MOTION TO STAY MG 04-29-2014
CURTAILMENT ORDER
04-29-2014 ORDER VACATING HEARING
04-30-2014 NOTICE OF LODGING CONSOLIDATED AGENCY RECORD
AND TRANSCRIPT WITH THE AGENCY
05-14-2014 NOTICE OF IGWA OBJECTION TO THE CONSOLIDATED
AGENCY RECORD AND TRANSCRIPT
05-27-2014 (FAX) ORDER SETTLING THE CONSOLIDATED AGENCY
RECORD AND TRANSCRIPT
05-27-2014 (FAX) NOTICE OF LODGING THE CONSOLIDATED
AGENCY RECORD AND TRANSCRIPT WITH THE
DISTRICT COURT
06-18-2014 NOTICE OF HEARING HH 06-30-2014 0130
06-19-2014 JOINT MOTION TO WAIVE PAGE LIMIT AND AMEND MG 06-20-2014
BRIEFING SCHEDULE
06-19-2014 STIPULATION AND JOINT MOTION TO ALLOW RANGEN MG 06-20-2014
TO FILE ONE SET OF BRIEFS COVERING APPEAL
AND CROSS APPEAL
06-20-2014 ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO WAIVE PAGE LIMIT AND
AMEND BRIEFING SCHEDULE
OPENING BRIEFS DUE: 07/11/14 BB 07-11-2014 0500
RESPONSE BRIEFS DUE: 08/06/14 BB 08-06-2014 0500
REPLY BRIEFS DUE: 08/21/14 BB 08-21-2014 0500
06-20-2014 ORDER CONSOLIDATING GOODING COUNTY CASE NO. 06-20-2014
CV-2014-179 INTO TWIN FALLS COUNTY CASE NO.
CV-2014-1338
06-23-2014 (FAX) IDWR MOTION TO AMEND BRIEFING SCHEDULE MG 06-25-2014
AND TO WAIVE PAGE LIMIT
06-25-2014 ORDER GRANTING IDWR MOTION TO AMEND BRIEFING
SCHEDULE AND TO WAIVE PAGE LIMIT
OPENING BRIEFS DUE: 07/11/14 BB 07-11-2014 0500
RESPONSE BRIEFS DUE: 08/08/14 BB 08-08-2014 0500
REPLY BRIEFS DUE: 08/21/14 BB 08-21-2014 0500
06-26-2014 RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO AUGMENT 06-26-2014
RECORD
06-26-2014 AFFIDAVIT OF JENNIFER S SUKOW
06-27-2014 CORRECTION TO RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO 06-27-2014
MOTION TO AUGMENT RECORD
06-27-2014 AFFIDAVIT OF GARRICK L BAXTER
06-27-2014 RANGEN INC RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO AUGMENT 06-27-2014
RECORD
06-27-2014 AFFIDAVIT OF CHARLES E BROCKWAY PHD IN
SUPPORT OF RANGEN INC RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION
TO MOTION TO AUGMENT RECORD
06-30-2014 HEARING HELD HH 06-30-2014 0130
06-30-2014 MINUTES
06-30-2014 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO AUGMENT RECORD
07-11-2014 LODGED: RANGEN INCS OPENING BRIEF
07-14-2014 LODGED: IGWAS OPENING BRIEF
08-08-2014 LODGED: FREMONT MADISON IRRIGATION DISTRICT'S
RESPONSE BRIEF
08-08-2014 LODGED: RANGEN INC'S RESPONSE BRIEF
08-08-2014 LODGED: IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES'
BRIEF IN RESPONSE TO RANGEN'S OPENING
BRIEF
08-08-2014 LODGED: SURFACE WATER COALITION'S JOINT
RESPONSE BRIEF
08-11-2014 LODGED: IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES'
BRIEF IN RESPONSE TO IGWA'S OPENING BRIEF
08-11-2014 LODGED: IGWA'S RESPONSE TO RANGEN'S OPENING
BRIEF
08-11-2014 LDGD: CITY OF POCATELLO'S RESPONSE BRIEF
08-21-2014 LODGED: RANGEN INC'S REPLY BRIEF
08-25-2014 LODGED: IGWA'S REPLY BRIEF
08-28-2014 HEARING HELD HH 08-28-2014 0130
08-28-2014 MINUTES
10-24-2014 MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER ON PETITION
FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
10-24-2014 JUDGMENT 5B 12-05-2014
11-07-2014 (FAX) CITY OF POCATELLO'S PETITION FOR MD 12-05-2014
REHEARING
11-07-2014 (FAX) IGWA'S PETITION FOR REHEARING AND MD 12-05-2014
CLARIFICATION
11-19-2014 NOTICE OF HEARING HH 12-02-2014 0130
11-20-2014 (FAX) LODGED: IGWA'S BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF
PETITION FOR REHEARING AND CLARIFICATION
11-21-2014 CITY OF POCATELLO BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF ITS
PETITION FOR REHEARING
12-02-2014 HEARING HELD HH 12-02-2014 0130
12-02-2014 MINUTES
12-05-2014 NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED (RANGEN) 12-05-2014
12-05-2014 ORDER DENYING PETITIONS FOR REHEARING
12-24-2014 IGWA'S NOTICE OF APPEAL 12-24-2014
01-09-2015 NOTICE OF LODGING (TRANSCRIPT)
01-09-2015 ORDER CONSOLIDATING APPEALS FOR PURPOSES OF
REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT AND CLERK'S RECORD
ONLY
01-12-2015 AMENDED ORDER CONSOLIDATING APPEALS FOR
PURPOSES OF REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT AND
CLERK'S RECORD ONLY
01-16-2015 (FAX) CITY OF POCATELLO'S NOTICE OF APPEAL 01-16-2015
02-03-2015 ORDER TO CONSOLIDATE WITH DOCKET NOS. 42772
AND 42775 (FOR PURPOSES OF CLERK'S RECORD
ONLY)
02-05-2015 CLERK'S RECORD ON APPEAL SERVED ON PARTIES
03-04-2015 (FAX) CITY OF POCATELLO'S OBJECTION TO HS 03-16-2015 0130
CLERK'S RECORD AND NOTICE OF HEARING
03-04-2015 IDWR'S OBJECTION TO THE CLERK'S RECORD 03-05-2015
03-04-2015 NOTICE OF HEARING FOR IDWR'S OBJECTION TO THE HS 03-16-2015 0130
CLERK'S RECORD
03-16-2015 ORDER ON OBJECTIONS TO CLERK'S RECORD
03-19-2015 CLERK'S SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD ON APPEAL SERVED
ON PARTIES / CLERK'S RECORD ON APPEAL
DEEMED SETTLED AND SENT TO SUPREME COURT
03-04-2016 SUPREME COURT ORDER/OPINION RE: DOCKET 42772
03-23-2016 REMITTITUR FROM IDAHO SUPREME COURT 03-23-2016
03-23-2016 NOTICE OF RECEIPT OF PAYMENT FOR RESPONDENTS'
AWARD OF COSTS AND ATTORNEY FEES
03-23-2016 SUPREME COURT ORDER/OPINION RE: DOCKET 42775
05-13-2016 REMITTITUR FROM IDAHO SUPREME COURT 05-13-2016
Return to Appeals Index