ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL SUMMARY REPORT
CV-2014-0000165
Return to Appeals Index
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL SUMMARY REPORT HTML19
04-19-2024
COURT CASE#: CV-2014-0000165
PETITIONER: ABERDEEN-SPRINGFIELD CANAL
COMPANY
COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY RELIEF
**** PARTIES INVOLVED ****
ABERDEEN-SPRINGFIELD CANAL P ATTY: RANDALL C BUDGE
" ATTY: CAROL TIPPI VOLYN
JEFFREY & CHANA DUFFIN P ATTY: RANDALL C BUDGE
" ATTY: CAROL TIPPI VOLYN
IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER R ATTY: GARRICK L BAXTER
" ATTY: JOHN HOMAN
" ATTY: MEGHAN CARTER
A & B IRRIGATION DISTRICT I ATTY: TRAVIS L THOMPSON
AMERICAN FALLS RESERVOIR I ATTY: W KENT FLETCHER
BURLEY IRRIGATION DISTRICT I ATTY: TRAVIS L THOMPSON
MILNER IRRIGATION DISTRICT I ATTY: MARTEN LAW LLP
MINIDOKA IRRIGATION DISTRI I ATTY: W KENT FLETCHER
NORTH SIDE CANAL COMPANY I ATTY: MARTEN LAW LLP
TWIN FALLS CANAL COMPANY I ATTY: MARTEN LAW LLP
**** ROA ENTRIES ****
06-06-2014 COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY RELIEF
06-06-2014 SUMMONS
06-06-2014 MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF TEMPORARY RESTRAINING MG 06-12-2014
ORDER AND ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE RE:
PRELIMINARY INJUCTION
06-06-2014 LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS'
MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF TEMPORARY
RESTRAINING ORDER AND ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
RE: PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
06-06-2014 TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER AND ORDER TO SHOW
CAUSE RE: PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
06-06-2014 AFFIDAVIT OF JEFFREY DUFFIN
06-06-2014 AFFIDAVIT OF STEVE HOWSER
06-12-2014 CORRECTED AFFIDAVIT OF JEFFREY DUFFIN
06-12-2014 ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE OF PROCESS
06-12-2014 ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR
TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER AND ORDER TO
SHOW CAUSE
06-13-2014 STIPULATION OF REASSIGNMENT
06-13-2014 ORDER GRANTING REASSIGNMENT
06-17-2014 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
06-19-2014 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S MOTION TO INTERVENE MG 07-18-2014
06-19-2014 LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF SURFACE
WATER COALITION'S MOTION TO INTERVENE
06-19-2014 AFFIDAVIT OF TRAVIS L THOMPSON IN SUPPORT OF
SURFACE WATER COALITION'S MOTION TO
INTERVENE
06-19-2014 NOTICE OF HEARING ON SURFACE WATER HS 07-10-2014 1030
COALITION'S MOTION TO INTERVENE
06-20-2014 (FAX) ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY 06-20-2014
RELIEF
06-30-2014 LODGED: PLAINTIFFS' MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION
TO SURFACE WATER COALITION'S MOTION TO
INTERVENE
07-08-2014 SURFACE WATER COALITIONS REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS 07-08-2014
MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO SURFACE WATER
COALITIONS MOTION TO INTERVENE
07-17-2014 PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT MD 04-08-2015
07-17-2014 LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS'
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
07-17-2014 SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF STEVEN T HOWSER
07-18-2014 ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO INTERVENE
07-18-2014 ORDER FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE SH 08-07-2014 0200
08-07-2014 HEARING HELD SH 08-07-2014 0200
08-07-2014 MINUTES
08-12-2014 (FAX) STIPULATION FOR SCHEDULING AND
PLANNING
09-05-2014 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS'
1ST DISCOVERY REQUESTS TO PLAINTIFFS
ABERDEEN-SPRINGFIELD CANAL COMPANY AND
JEFFREY & CHANA DUFFIN
09-30-2014 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF IDWR'S FIRST SET OF
INTERROGATORIES, REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION
AND REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS TO PLAINTIFF
ABERDEEN-SPRINGFIELD CANAL COMPANY (FAXED)
10-06-2014 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO
DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS' FIRST REQUESTS FOR
ADMISSION TO PLAINTIFFS JEFFREY AND CHANA
DUFFIN
10-06-2014 NOTICE OF SERVICE PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO
DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS' FIRST REQUESTS FOR
ADMISSION TO PLAINTIFF ABERDEEN-SPRINGFIELD
CANAL COMPANY
10-08-2014 (FAX) NOTICE OF SERVICE OF IDWR'S FIRST SET
OF INTERROGATORIES, REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION
AND REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS TO PLAINTIFFS
JEFFREY AND CHANA DUFFIN
10-08-2014 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO
DEFENDANT IDWR'S FIRST SET OF REQUESTS FOR
ADMISSIONS TO PLAINTIFF ABERDEEN-SPRINGFIELD
CANAL COMPANY
10-08-2014 PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT IDWR'S 10-08-2014
FIRST SET OF REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS TO
PLAINTIFF ABERDEEN-SPRINFIELD CANAL COMPANY
11-10-2014 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF
11-20-2014 CORRECTED AFFIDAVIT OF JEFFREY DUFFIN
11-20-2014 CORRECTED SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF STEVEN T HOWSER
11-20-2014 CORRECTED FIRST AFFIDAVIT OF STEVE HOWSER
11-26-2014 NOTICE OF SERVICE
12-11-2014 NOTICE SETTING HEARING -- SUMMARY JUDGMENT HV 02-24-2015 0130
12-12-2014 PLAINTIFFS DISCLOSURE OF LAY AND EXPERT
WITNESSES
12-19-2014 NOTICE OF SERVICE
01-12-2015 SCHEDULING ORDER, NOTICE OF TRIAL SETTING AND TV 06-17-2015 0900
INITIAL PRETRIAL ORDER
01-12-2015 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE PV 06-10-2015 0130
01-14-2015 (FAX) IDWR DISCLOSURE OF LAY AND EXPERT
WITNESSES
01-28-2015 SURFACE WATER COALITION'S DISCLOSURE OF
WITNESSES
02-11-2015 AMENDED NOTICE OF HEARING (SUMMARY JUDGMENT) HH 04-01-2015 0130
02-23-2015 (FAX) NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES
TECUM OF JEFFREY DUFFIN
02-23-2015 (FAX) NOTICE OF TAKING OF 36(B)(6)
DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM
03-04-2015 LODGED: IDWR'S MOTION AND MEMORANDUM IN MG 04-08-2015
SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT
03-04-2015 AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY
JUDGMENT
03-04-2015 SURFACE WATER COALITIONS MOTION FOR SUMMARY MG 04-08-2015
JUDGMENT
03-04-2015 LDGD: MEMO IN SUPPORT OF SURFACE WATER
COALITIONS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
03-04-2015 AFFIDAVIT OF PAUL ARRINGTON
03-04-2015 NOTICE OF HEARING ON SURFACE WATER COALITIONS HH 04-01-2015 0130
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
03-05-2015 (FAX) NOTICE OF HEARING FOR IDWRS MOTION FOR HH 04-01-2015 0130
SUMMARY JUDGMENT
03-18-2015 IDWR RESPONSE TO ASCC MOTION FOR SUMMARY 03-18-2015
JUDGMENT
03-18-2015 SURFACE WATER COALITIONS RESPONSE IN 03-18-2015
OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR SUMMARY
JUDGMENT
03-19-2015 PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO IDWR 03-19-2015
AND SWC MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
03-19-2015 AFFIDAVIT OF RANDALL C BUDGE
03-25-2015 IDWRS REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO IDWRS 03-25-2015
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMEMT
03-25-2015 REPLY IN SUPPORT OF SURFACE WATER COALITIONS 03-25-2015
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
03-25-2015 (FAX) PLAINTIFFS REPLY TO IDWR AND SWC 03-25-2015
RESPONSES
04-01-2015 HEARING HELD HH 04-01-2015 0130
04-01-2015 MINUTES
04-08-2015 ORDER ON MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
04-08-2015 JUDGMENT 5B 05-20-2015
04-14-2015 NOTICE CHANGING TELECONFERENCING CALL-IN
NUMBERS
Return to Appeals Index