ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL SUMMARY REPORT
CV-2015-0021376
Return to Appeals Index
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL SUMMARY REPORT HTML19
09-26-2024
COURT CASE#: CV-2015-0021376
PETITIONER: BALLENTYNE DITCH COMPANY
IN THE MATTER OF ACCOUNTING FOR
DISTRIBUTION OF WATER TO THE FEDERAL
ON-STREAM RESERVOIRS IN WATER DISTRICT
63
**** PARTIES INVOLVED ****
NO ACTIVE PARTIES TO THE APPEAL
**** ROA ENTRIES ****
12-17-2015 DITCH COMPANIES' PETITION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
12-22-2015 NOTICE OF REASSIGNMENT
12-23-2015 PROCEDURAL ORDER GOVERNING JUDICIAL REVIEW OF
FINAL ORDER OF DIRECTOR OF IDAHO
DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
SETTLED RECORD AND TRANSCRIPTS TO BE
LODGED W/COURT BY: 02/03/16 ZB 02-03-2016 0500
12-23-2015 ORAL ARGUMENT: 05/10/16 HV 05-10-2016 0130
12-24-2015 NOTICE OF LODGING AGENCY RECORD & TRANSCRIPT
WITH THE AGENCY
12-28-2015 MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE MG 12-30-2015
12-28-2015 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE: SUEZ WATER IDAHO
12-30-2015 ORDER CONSOLIDATING PROCEEDINGS 12-30-2015
01-07-2016 OBJECTION TO AGENCY RECORD AND MOTION TO MG 01-19-2016
AUGMENT
01-07-2016 (FAX) DITCH COMPANIES' OBJECTION TO AGENCY 01-07-2016
RECORD LODBED BY IDWR
01-11-2016 (FAX) SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTION TO AGENCY RECORD MG 01-19-2016
AND MOTION TO AUGMENT
01-19-2016 NOTICE OF LODGING THE SETTLED AGENCY RECORD
AND TRANSCRIPT WITH THE DISTRICT COURT
01-19-2016 ORDER SETTLING THE AGENCY RECORD AND
TRANSCRIPT
01-19-2016 AGENCY'S CERTIFICATE OF RECORD
02-04-2016 ORDER TREATING APPEARANCE AS MOTION TO
INTERVENE AND GRANTING SAME
02-18-2016 (FAX) MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE OVERLENGTH MG 02-18-2016
BRIEF
02-18-2016 (FAX) LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
FOR LEAVE TO FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF
02-19-2016 ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE
OVERLENGTH BRIEF
02-19-2016 (FAX) DITCH COMPANIES' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO MG 02-19-2016
FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF
02-19-2016 (FAX) LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF THE
DITCH COMPANIES' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE
OVERLENGTH BRIEF
02-19-2016 ORDER GRANTING DITCH COMPANIES' MOTION FOR
LEAVE TO FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF
02-22-2016 (FAX) STIPULATED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF MG 02-22-2016
BRIEFING DEADLINES
02-22-2016 (FAX) AFFIDAVIT OF DANIEL V STEENSON IN
SUPPORT OF STIPULATED MOTION FOR EXTENSION
OF BRIEFING DEADLINES
02-22-2016 ORDER GRANTING STIPULATED MOTION FOR
EXTENSION OF TIME
PETITIONERS' BRIEF(S) DUE: 03/08/16 BB 03-08-2016 0500
RESPONDENTS' BRIEF(S) DUE: 04/05/16 BB 04-05-2016 0500
REPLY BRIEF(S) DUE: 04/26/16 BB 04-26-2016 0500
03-08-2016 LDGED: BOISE PROJECT BOARD OF CONTROL
PETITIONERS BRIEF
03-08-2016 DITCH COMPANIES MOTION TO STAY MD 04-06-2016
03-08-2016 LDGD: DITCH COMPANIES MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT
OF MOTION TO STAY
03-08-2016 LDGD: DITCH COMPANIES OPENING BRIEF
03-09-2016 (FAX) REQUEST FOR REASONABLE ATTORNEY FEES MF 03-09-2016
AND COSTS ON JUDICIAL REVIEW
03-15-2016 NOTICE OF HEARING HH 04-05-2016 0130
03-18-2016 LDGD: SUEZ'S BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO DITCH
COMPANIES' MOTION TO STAY
03-21-2016 RESPONDENTS' RESPONSE TO DITCH COMPANIES' 03-21-2016
MOTION TO STAY
03-22-2016 (FAX) NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS
03-23-2016 (FAX) MOTION TO FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF MG 03-28-2016
03-23-2016 (FAX) LODGED: RESPONDENTS MEMORANDUM IN
SUPPORT OF MOTION TO FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF
03-23-2016 SUEZ MOTION TO FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF MG 03-28-2016
03-23-2016 (FAX) LDGED: SUEZ MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF
MOTION TO FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF
03-28-2016 ORDER GRANTING MOTIONS TO FILE OVERLENGTH
BRIEFS
03-29-2016 (FAX) LODGED: REPLY MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF
DITCH COMPANIES' MOTION TO STAY
03-31-2016 DITCH COMPANIES REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO 03-31-2016
STAY
04-01-2016 (FAX) MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME FOR MG 04-04-2016
FILING RESPONDENTS' BRIEF
04-01-2016 (FAX) AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR
EXTENSION OF TIME FOR FILING RESPONDENTS'
BRIEF
04-04-2016 ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
04-05-2016 HEARING HELD HH 04-05-2016 0130
04-05-2016 MINUTES
04-06-2016 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO STAY
04-06-2016 ORDER VACATING AND RESETTING ORAL ARGUMENT HH 07-11-2016 0900
04-08-2016 LODGED: BRIEF FOR RESPONDENTS' IDWR AND
GARY SPACKMAN
04-08-2016 LODGED: INTERVENOR SUEZ'S RESPONSE BRIEF
04-22-2016 (FAX) MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME FOR MG 04-22-2016
FILING PETITIONERS' REPLY BRIEF MF 04-22-2016
04-22-2016 AFFIDAVIT OF DANIEL V STEENSON IN SUPPORT OF
MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME FOR FILING
PETITIONERS' REPLY BRIEF
04-22-2016 (FAX) AMENDED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME MG 04-22-2016
FOR FILING PETITIONERS' REPLY BRIEF
04-22-2016 ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
REPLY BRIEFS DUE: 05/06/16 RB 05-06-2016 0500
05-02-2016 RESPONDENTS' CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE AND
NOTICE OF ERRATA
05-05-2016 (FAX) SECOND MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE MG 05-05-2016
OVERLENGTH BRIEF
05-05-2016 (FAX) LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF SECOND
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF
05-05-2016 (FAX) DITCH COMPANIES' SECOND MOTION FOR MG 05-05-2016
LEAVE TO FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF
05-05-2016 (FAX) LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF THE
DITCH COMANIES' SECOND MOTION FOR LEAVE TO
FILE OVERLENGTH BRIEF
05-05-2016 ORDER GRANTING MOTIONS TO FILE OVERLENGTH
BRIEF
05-06-2016 LODGED: PETITIONERS' REPLY BRIEF
05-06-2016 LDGD: DITCH COMPANIES REPLY BRIEF
07-11-2016 HEARING HELD HH 07-11-2016 0900
07-11-2016 MINUTES
09-01-2016 MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER
09-01-2016 JUDGMENT 5B 10-13-2016
09-09-2016 (FAX) PETITION FOR REHEARING (IDWR) MD 11-14-2016
09-22-2016 (FAX)IRRIGATION ENTITIES' PETITION FOR MD 11-14-2016
REHEARING
09-22-2016 (FAX) PETITION FOR REHEARING (SUEZ) MD 11-14-2016
09-23-2016 LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS'
PETITION FOR REHEARING
10-06-2016 LODGED: SUEZ'S MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF
PETITION FOR REHEARING
10-06-2016 LODGED: MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF THE
IRRIGATORS' PETITION FOR REHEARING
11-14-2016 ORDER DENYING REHEARING
12-06-2016 DITCH COMPANIES NOTICE OF APPEAL 12-06-2016
12-06-2016 INFO ONLY: CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF APPEAL
SENT TO SUPREME COURT FOR DITCH COMPANIES
12-23-2016 NOTICE OF APPEAL F/B IDWR 12-23-2016
12-23-2016 SUEZ'S NOTICE OF CROSS-APPEAL 12-23-2016
12-23-2016 N0TICE OF APPEAL F/B BPBC 12-23-2016
12-30-2016 INFO ONLY: CLERK'S CERTIFICATES OF APPEAL
SENT TO SUPREME COURT FOR IDWR/SUEZ/BPBC
01-13-2017 SUEZ'S SECOND NOTICE OF CROSS-APPEAL 01-13-2017
01-13-2017 INFO ONLY: CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF 2ND CROSS-
APPEAL FROM SUEZ SENT TO SUPREME COURT
01-24-2017 ORDER CONSOLIDATING APPEAL NOS. 44677 44745
AND 44746 FOR RECORD AND TRANSCRIPTS ONLY
02-16-2017 NOTICE OF LODGING (2 TRANSCRIPTS)
03-27-2017 INFO ONLY: CLERK'S RECORD ON APPEAL SENT TO
SUPREME COURT
09-17-2019 NOTICE OF COURT'S INTENT TO VACATE ORDERS
AND REMAND
OBJECTIONS DUE: 10/15/19 8B 10-15-2019 0500
10-16-2019 ORDER VACATING ORDERS AND REMANDING TO THE
IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
10-16-2019 JUDGMENT 5B 11-27-2019
10-22-2019 ORDER VACATING ORDERS AND REMANDING TO THE
IDWR (WITH CORRECTED CERTIFICATE OF MAILING)
10-22-2019 JUDGMENT (WITH CORRECTED CERT OF MAILING) 5B 12-03-2019
12-11-2019 ORDER GRANTING SECOND JOINT MOTION TO
DISMISS APPEAL (44677-2016)
12-11-2019 ORDER GRANTING SECOND JOINT MOTION TO
DISMISS APPEAL (44745-2017)
12-11-2019 ORDER GRANTING SECOND JOINT MOTION TO
DISMISS APPEAL (44746-2017)
12-11-2019 REMITTITUR FROM IDAHO SUPREME COURT (FOR 12-11-2019
(FOR 44746-2017
12-11-2019 REMITTITUR FROM IDAHO SUPREME COURT 12-11-2019
(FOR 44677-2016)
12-11-2019 REMITTITUR FROM IDAHO SUPREME COURT 12-11-2019
(FOR 44745-2017)
12-11-2019 CLOSED 12-11-2019
Return to Appeals Index